The numbers on loyalty programs are hard to argue with. Returning customers spend 67% more than new customers. Increasing customer retention by just 5% can increase profits by 25–95%. And customers enrolled in a loyalty program visit 35% more frequently than non-members.
For Square restaurants, the question isn't whether to have a loyalty program—it's whether yours is actually working for your business, or just working for whoever built the loyalty platform.
In 2025, the most effective loyalty programs for Square merchants aren't punch cards or even Square Loyalty used in isolation. They're integrated into a branded mobile app where customers earn points, track rewards, and feel connected to your brand every single day.
The Gap in Standalone Loyalty Programs
Most Square merchants start with Square Loyalty. It's built in, it's simple, and it works. But it has limitations that become obvious as you try to grow:
- Customers must remember to check their points—there's no direct notification channel
- Square Loyalty lives inside the Square ecosystem, not inside your branded experience
- There's no app with your logo sitting on the customer's home screen
- Advanced segmentation and automated campaigns require additional tools
This is where an integrated mobile loyalty program changes everything.
How It Works: Orda + Square Loyalty
Orda integrates directly with Square Loyalty. When a customer orders through your Orda-powered branded app:
- Payment processes through Square — no change to your existing workflow
- Square Loyalty points are automatically credited to their account
- The customer sees their balance and reward progress inside your branded app
- Orda triggers automated push notifications for loyalty milestones, expirations, and rewards
Your existing Square Loyalty setup doesn't change. Orda puts it inside a beautiful, branded mobile experience that keeps your business top-of-mind every day.
Beyond Points: 3 Advanced Loyalty Strategies That Work in 2025
1. Preloaded Gift Cards (The Starbucks Model)
Starbucks' most profitable product isn't coffee—it's its preloaded card system. Customers add $25–$50 to their account upfront. They feel a sense of "free money" when they spend it. And they consistently spend more per visit when drawing from a preloaded balance than when paying fresh each time.
Orda supports preloaded cards natively for Square merchants. For a coffee shop or juice bar, this is one of the highest-leverage features you can activate. A customer who loads $50 onto your app has already committed to returning. They've paid—now they just decide what to order next time.
2. Coffee and Beverage Subscription Plans
Monthly subscription plans are one of the fastest-growing revenue models in food and beverage. For $25–$40 a month, customers get a daily drink (or a fixed number per month). They feel like they're getting a deal. You get guaranteed recurring revenue—and a customer who visits every single day.
Orda supports subscription plans for Square merchants. You define the terms; Orda handles billing and usage tracking integrated with your Square account. Several Orda coffee shop merchants now have hundreds of active subscribers generating reliable monthly recurring revenue independent of foot traffic fluctuations.
3. Tiered Loyalty Levels
Gold, Silver, Bronze. VIP, Regular, New. The naming doesn't matter—the psychology does. Customers who achieve a higher loyalty tier spend more to maintain their status and visit more frequently to keep earning.
With Orda, you can create custom loyalty tiers displayed prominently in your branded app. "You're 3 orders away from Gold status" is one of the most effective retention messages in food and beverage. It creates urgency, reward anticipation, and habit—all at once.
Turning Loyalty Data Into Revenue Intelligence
The real power of a mobile loyalty program isn't just repeat visits—it's the data you collect.
Every order through your Orda app tells you:
- Who your most valuable customers are and how much they spend annually
- What they order most frequently and when
- How they respond to different types of promotions
- Which customers are at risk of lapsing
This data, layered on top of your Square reporting, gives you an unprecedented view of your business. You make smarter staffing decisions, better inventory orders, and more targeted marketing campaigns—because you know exactly who your customers are and what they want.
Your 3-Step Launch Plan
Step 1: Set up Square Loyalty (if you haven't already). Define your points structure—how many points per dollar spent, and what each reward tier unlocks. Keep it simple to start.
Step 2: Launch your branded Orda app. Connect to Square at getorda.com and your Square Loyalty program is automatically displayed inside your app, synced in real time.
Step 3: Activate automated loyalty campaigns. Turn on the win-back notification (fires when a customer hasn't ordered in 14 days), the milestone nudge (fires when they're one order from a reward), and the birthday reward. These run on autopilot and compound over time.
Most Orda merchants see a measurable increase in repeat visit frequency within the first 30 days of launching their loyalty-integrated app.
Ready to build a loyalty program your customers actually love? Get started with Orda today and launch your branded Square loyalty app.
